What if the best cruises aren’t the ones where you follow the rules—but the ones where you quietly break them?
I’m not talking about getting kicked off the ship. I mean ignoring those “unwritten” cruise commandments everyone swears by—the ones that promise the perfect vacation but somehow make it stressful instead.
It took me a few trips to realize: the secret to loving cruising isn’t doing what everyone says you should. It’s daring to do the opposite.
Because once you stop following the crowd, that’s when your cruise finally feels like yours.
The “Unreal” Cabin I Book Every Time
People act like I’ve confessed a crime when I say I always book inside cabins. “But how do you survive without a balcony?” they ask. Simple—I sleep better, spend less, and enjoy cruising more. Turns out, skipping the view is the smartest upgrade most cruisers never even think about.
Read any cruise blog or scan forum threads, and you’ll instantly see the divide. Balcony loyalists swear sea breezes are priceless. Common comment? “I wouldn’t even consider cruising any other way.” But budget-savvy cruisers? They’ll tell you that dark, quiet cabins feel like sleeping in a high-end spa pod—especially after a late-night deck party.
Admittedly, I used to cave to pressure to book the “real cruise experience.” Then one day it hit me: I was paying a fortune for views I barely noticed. If I want to stare at the sea, there are endless decks where I can do that for free.
Now, my money goes to specialty dining, shore adventures, or an extra sailing each year. Once you try it, you won’t miss that balcony—you’ll miss all the savings you left floating away.
Balcony traditionalists swear I’m missing the whole point of cruising. Maybe. But I’ve done both—and my wallet and sleep say otherwise. So, what’s worth more to you: the view you barely use, or another cruise you can actually take?
The Habit That Gets Me Glares on Every Sailing
It’s one of the most controversial cruise “rules” that I have no issues breaking—removing auto gratuities. In fact, I’ve stopped telling people I do this because of the stares, silent judging, and even insults I have to endure. The point is: I’m not dodging tips, I’m making them personal.
Personally, I prefer handing cash straight to the crew who actually made my cruise unforgettable. It’s all about connection, not convenience. Of course, not everyone on Facebook or Cruise Critic agrees. Many call it “unfair,” and it doesn’t reward background staff. But many people are in my boat, saying it’s the “most genuine way to show appreciation.”
Some cruisers say I’m stirring trouble. Maybe I am. But when you see how fast a real thank-you changes someone’s day, you start questioning who that auto gratuities really serves.
What’s your take? Would you rather tip a spreadsheet or personally thank the bartender who just remembered how you like your mojito?
The One Night I Break Every Cruise Rule
Seasoned cruisers say it’s the one night everyone should attend—formal night. I went once and swore, “never again.” Getting dressed in a tux, polishing shoes, and posing for photos, isn’t my idea of “Caribbean fun in the sun.” For me, there’s nothing better than grabbing a pizza and watching the ship glow from the deck.
Traditionalists say that glamming up at sea is what cruising is all about. “It keeps the magic alive,” they claim. Maybe that was true 30 or 40 years ago. But most cruisers I speak with say they prefer sandals and cargo shorts to sequins and dress pants.
Some may say that I’m killing tradition, and I get that. But formal nights seem to be one of those traditions that’s slowly slipping away. Many cruise lines like Norwegian (NCL) now have “smart-casual,” not formal evenings.
Here’s the thing: If you’re sweating through a suit while I’m watching the sunset in flip-flops—who’s really winning?
When Everyone Else Bolts Ashore, I Do the Opposite
You’ll see the pandemonium on every cruise. As soon as the ship docks, everyone’s sprinting for gangways, clutching tote bags like it’s a Black Friday sale. But who says that every port day means abandoning ship for an overpriced shore excursion?
I’ve learned to do things differently. I order a latte, claim a lounger, and watch the port empty. It’s quiet, calm, and for a few glorious hours, the ship feels like it’s mine.
Reddit threads always light up when the “go ashore” vs. “stay on board” debate comes up. Port lovers swear I’m wasting time, but veterans know the secret: the best “excursion” is sometimes no excursion at all. No crowds, no lines, no rush—just silence, sunshine, and maybe a dip in the empty pool.
If exploring every port makes you happy, go for it. I’ve also enjoyed fabulous excursions in Aruba, St. Thomas, San Juan, and Roatán. But don’t call it adventure if you never stop to breathe.
My Morning Ritual That Baffles Buffet Lovers
You know that “obligatory” line at the breakfast buffet? You’ll never see me there because I learned how to enjoy relaxing mornings. I get room service to find me—coffee, fruit, maybe a bagel or pastry. Then I head to a quiet deck I scouted day one, where no one goes this early.
Avoiding the breakfast stampede is my version of a sunrise suite, minus the balcony price. Many cruisers on Reddit wonder, “Why pay for room service when the buffet’s free?” But many don’t realize that free breakfast service is still available on many cruise lines.
If I want something more substantial than coffee and a pastry? I head to the Main Dining Room, where you can enjoy a freshly cooked breakfast in peace that hasn’t been manhandled by a hundred tongs.
Be honest, which sounds more like a vacation—beating the omelet line or sipping in silence while the ship wakes up?
How I Outsmart Cruise Excursion Prices (Legally)
Cruise lines and even some veterans love to scare rookie cruisers about booking excursions on their own. You’d think that the second you step off the pier, pirates are waiting. Truth is, I’ve saved hundreds organizing DIY port days. A little research, book with a private, trusted operator, and suddenly you’re paying half price.
Every time I mention it online, the safety brigade shows up with their typical questions. “What happens if you miss the ship?” “What about insurance?” All fair points. But here’s what they miss: independent operators live on reviews. They’re often more punctual, more flexible, and a lot more fun than the bus tours packed with forty sunburned strangers.
I get it, DIY shore excursions aren’t for everyone. But do it right, and you’ll spend less, see more, and be back on board well before sailaway. But ask yourself, are you paying extra for peace of mind, or spending over the odds for the same view?
The One Package I Refuse to Play the Math Game With
Every cruise has that one table with someone doing the math for the drink package. They’ve calculated how much they need to drink to get their money’s worth. The beverage package is no longer liberating—it’s a challenge to beat. And guess what? Many cruisers don’t drink enough to justify the cost.
Debates about drink packages rage on Cruise Critic and Reddit threads. Half the crowd swears the package gives them “freedom not to bother about budget on a cruise.” The rest? They’re stumbling back to their cabin, debating whether they really needed that last margarita at all.
The drinks package is one cruise tradition I’m happy to avoid. I’d rather budget for a few drinks and enjoy a perfect espresso martini than twelve watered-down mojitos. But here’s what many people miss: When did a vacation become about breaking even rather than just enjoying yourself?
The Grand Event I Make Sure Never to Attend
Sailaway is one of those cruise rituals that some cruisers feel they cannot miss. But after a few sailings, they all start to feel the same. Crowds packed on the deck like sardines, horns blaring, and drinks spilling everywhere. Everyone’s pretending the chaos is “absolutely magical.” Really?
Savvy cruisers know how to get the best out of sailaway. Grab a drink, find a quiet aft deck or observation lounge, and let the ship slip away in peace. They’re happy to let the crazy conga line do what it does on the Lido deck. Meanwhile, they’re toasting the view everyone else is too busy to notice.
Some say the party energy is what makes sailaway unforgettable. Maybe the first time, sure. But after that, it’s just the same playlist and the same plastic cups. Here’s the real question: Is sailaway about joining the crowd—or finally learning you don’t have to?
The Cruise Party I Secretly Avoid
It must be one of the most overrated evenings on a cruise vacation—the Captain’s Gala. While some love getting into formal wear, others say it’s nothing special. It’s all flashing cameras, clinking glasses, and small talk about nothing. Honestly? You can enjoy better dining experiences in specialty restaurants.
Cruise veterans love the Captain’s Gala because it’s a reminder of a bygone era of ocean liners. To them, cruising is about pomp and handshakes. Others prefer to enjoy more relaxed evenings on board, doing as they please, dressing as they wish, and avoiding any occasion that’s stiff and formal.
Some say it’s about respect and tradition—but memories? An overpriced photo for the scrapbook. Others want a sunset they’ll actually remember. Which one sounds more like a moment worth keeping?
Why I Never Rush to Board (and Never Regret It)
Read any cruise blog or dive into cruise forum discussions, and you’ll get a ton of hacks to be first on board. But what’s the reality? Typically, lines wrapped around the terminal, hauling luggage through crowds, and all the time stressing as if the ship would leave without them.
Smart cruisers know how to play embarkation day to their advantage. Yes, they get to the port a day early, but they board later. That way, there’s no pushing through photo ops, no elbowing for elevators, or waiting for cabins to open. They stroll on, drop bags, and head straight to lunch.
Cruise forums can’t seem to agree on this one. Some cruisers swear by “getting on early to start the fun.” They don’t want to miss anything. But for others, starting the cruise vacation stressed and worked up is the last thing they want to do.
What’s your experience? Is smart cruising being first on the ship or the first to actually relax?
The Dress-Up Nights I’ll Never Join
Theme nights really split the opinions of cruisers. Half of them say that no cruise is worth it if you don’t attend a themed night. They pack pirate outfits, neon wigs, and a bunch of outfits as if they were attending an ABBA revival. Others? They come for vacation, not costume contests.
Themed parties are fun to watch, just not worth hijacking half my suitcase. Some would argue that dressing up “brings the ship to life.” But others will say that it’s more peer pressure than pleasure, especially when sweating in polyester and a wig under deck lights.
Where do you stand? Are theme nights the heartbeat of cruising? Or is it just forced fun that belongs to the Instagram crowd and cruise line marketing teams?
The One Cruise “Homework” I Refuse to Do
I used to fall into the trap of planning a cruise vacation with military precision. The daily planner was color-coded with highlighters, all activities almost timed to the minute. Then I realized—I’m on vacation, not at work. Now, my planner stays blank, and my days feel like they’re mine.
To be fair, the planner has its place. After all, who wants to miss showtimes, trivia, or snagging a good seat at dinner? But mapping out every hour? You stop noticing the quiet moments and return home feeling like you need another vacation.
So maybe it’s not about skipping the schedule entirely. Perhaps it’s knowing when to close it. Because sometimes, the best part of the day is the one you didn’t plan at all.
The “Unmissable” Shows I Always Miss
Every cruise, there’s someone insisting the headline show is “unmissable.” And sure, I’ve enjoyed a few in the past—tight choreography, strong vocals, and a few laughs. But for every outstanding performance, there are another two or three that feel like they’ve run aground in the 90s. Definitely not worth it.
After a few disappointments, I’ve stopped viewing cruise shows as must-haves. Some tribute bands were like a bad karaoke night. Some shows were less Broadway and more buffet cabaret. And the comedy? Let’s just say that some punchlines sank faster than an anchor in rough seas.
So, I pick my shows like my cocktails—quality over quantity. Sometimes that means skipping the theater entirely and catching a real show: the sea, the stars, and not a single laugh track in sight.
Turns Out, the Best Rules Are the Ones You Break
Rookie cruisers often make the mistake of chasing everything—first onboard, busiest buffet, the loudest party—because everyone else does. They want to “make the most of their vacation.” But savvy cruisers learn to make their own rules and claim the moments they really want. Here’s the secret: your best cruise starts when you stop copying someone else’s.
Related articles:
